missclasification of Polish Notes

4 posts • 55回閲覧

This message aims at: requesting the modification of a banknote in the catalogue

Status: Rejected
Upvotes: 1
Downvotes: 1

Poland currently has banknotes in 6 denominations, issued in 3 emissions (the first date is the date on the banknote, and the second is the date it was put into circulation):
1 EMISSION: (1st banknote design).
- 10 zlotys (1994/1995)
- 20 zlotys (1994/1995)
- 50 zlotys (1994/1995)
- 100 zlotys (1994/1995)
- 200 zlotys (1994/1995)

2 EMISSION: (2nd banknote design)
- 10 zlotys (2012/2014)
- 20 zlotys (2012/2014)
- 50 zlotys (2012/2014)
- 100 zlotys (2012/2014)
- 200 zlotys (2015/2016)
- 500 zlotys (2016/2017)

3 EMISSION: (same banknote design as the 2nd emission)
- 10 zlotys (2016/2017)
- 20 zlotys (2016/2017)
- 50 zlotys (2017/2018)
- 100 zlotys (2018/2019)
- 200 zlotys (2021/2022)
- 500 zlotys (2017/2017)
 

In the numista catalog, these 3 banknotes emissions were divided into 2 banknotes:
1 banknote (N#202134) - 1st emission
2 banknote (N#206814) - 2nd and 3rd emissions, as they have the same design, only the date differs.
 

However, I have noticed that in the case of a coin, if the coins are made of a different material or only covered with a layer of a different material then the Numista catalog classifies them as 2 separate coins (e.g. 50 groszy 2017-2019 and 50 groszt 2019-2024 - the first coin is made of cupper-nickel and the second is covered with an additional layer of iron).
 

Hence, the question, as I found a note on the National Bank of Poland's website that the banknotes put into circulation since 2017 are additionally coated with a “protective layer that increases the durability of banknotes in circulation.” That is, all banknotes of the 3rd emission and the 500 zloty banknote of the 2nd emission.

So I ask you guys, in this situation, should we also do the same as for coins? This would mean creating new categories for banknotes:
- 10 zlotys (2016/2017)
- 20 zlotys (2016/2017)
- 50 zlotys (2017/2018)
- 100 zlotys (2018/2019)
- 200 zlotys (2021/2022)

Without the 500 zlotys, because both 500 zlotys banknotes contain this special layer, so it would remain the same.

I'm asking your opinion on this matter.

Generally speaking, if there is no change sufficient to require a different image, then banknotes are grouped together in a listing. 


The coating on the 2nd issue (emission) does not alter the appearance of the note. As such, I consider that it should be mentioned in the dates section rather than as a separate listing.

Status changed to Rejected (Jarcek, 2 1月 2025, 13:41)

Yes, change would have to be more significant. I wonder how many notes are like that and nobody even knows.

Catalogue administrator

Jarcek

I wonder how many notes are like that and nobody even knows.

Possibly quite a few!

» Forum policy

使用されているタイムゾーンは UTC+2:00 です。
現在の時刻は {24時間表記の時間}:{分} です。