Duplicate - 1/2 Groat of Alexander Jagiellon, Poland or Lithuania [解決]

4 posts • 65回閲覧

This message aims at: requesting the modification of a coin in the catalogue

Status: Done
Upvotes: 0
Downvotes: 0

N#31088

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces343561.html

 

Polish entry is in wrong country. Obverse lettering tells his Lithuanian title.

 

Maybe move information from Polish page to Lithuanian and delete Polish entry. Then I'll check if other updates are needed in regular modification request.

Status changed to Started (tdziemia, 12 7月 2024, 13:00)

OK.  

 

It may be difficult to harmonize the two because #31088 has the subtypes split according to legend variants, and #343561  according to the Kopicki subtypes.  As there are different numbers of date lines, there are likely to be some problems, but I will work on it when I return home from some travel (Sunday).

If we use the set of 5 date lines from #343561 (Poland) based on the Kopicki subtypes, there is no question about where to move any of the members from #31088, but we lose some detail (legend variants).  

If we use the set of date lines from #31088, we have a problem of how to move the members from the Kop. 3226 date line in #343561 into the different legend variants.  But this only affects a handful of users' coins, who would be moved to the subtype with highest frequency, so I think this is the best approach.  

 

So we wil start with #31088 and modify the date lines to look like this, then move over users from #343561: 

 

Kopicki 3222 - Gothic letters both sides, no circle around rider

Kopicki 3223 - Gothic letters both sides, circle around rider; ALEXANDRI

Kopicki 3223 - Gothic letters both sides, circle around rider; ALEXANDR

Kopicki 3224 - Gothic letters rider side only

Kopicki 3225 - Gothic letters eagle side only

Kopicki 3226 - Roman letters both sides; ALEXAND/MAGNI DVC LITVANI

Kopicki 3226 - Roman letters both sides; ALEXAND/MAGNI DVC LITVANIE

Kopicki 3226 - Roman letters both sides; ALEXANDR/MAGNI DVC LITVANIE

Kopicki 3226 - Roman letters both sides; ALEXANDRI/MAGNI DVC LITVANIE

Kopicki 3226 - Roman letters both sides; ALEXANDRI/MAGNI DVCI LITVANIE

Kopicki 3226 - Roman letters both sides; ALEXNDRI/MAGNI DVC LITVANIE

 

And, finally, the obverse and reverse will be switched to be in better conformance with the guidelines (the issuer name is on the eagle side).

 

I will let this sit for a few days in case there are comments/suggestions.

Status changed to Done (tdziemia, 21 7月 2024, 23:25)

Now done.

» Forum policy

使用されているタイムゾーンは UTC+2:00 です。
現在の時刻は {24時間表記の時間}:{分} です。