A coin or not a coin?

11 posts • 220回閲覧

» Quick access to the last post

It is not clear, which policy is chosen.

 

By Standard Catalog of World Coins the Burkina Faso issue

(source: https://www.delcampe.net/en_GB/collectables/coins-banknotes/coins/burkina-faso/rhinoceros-rarety-burkina-faso-6000-francs-4-africa-2003-unc-mint-lustre-in-holder-low-start-no-reserve-1920823857.html )

is not just defined as coin but was given proudly number ΚΜ#1!

At the same time Numista ignored that fact and keeps the issue from coin collectors somewhere away. So the question is obvious:
is it a coin?
is it a souvenir?

 

Clearly that in any case the small mintage in the first thousand pcs makes the item a real gem in any collection. 

Alexander from Cyprus
eucoins.byethost9.com
My suggestions https://t.me/enjoyyourcollection

Imo this is exonumia. In Burkina Faso you can definitly not use it to buy anything.
I guess it is not even been there…

...you can run,  but you can't hide...

All pieces with that elephant in front of Africa are exonumia made by a private issue. There were not only Burkina but other “hard to get” countries. Even the mint numbers should be a lie since those “coins” were very common in the market.

Thank you for your opinions, all that is common for many commemorative coins. Though it seems, that these opinions are in obvious contradiction with the statement of Standard Catalog of World Coins: KM#1 (it is already written, just enough to read the first post twice). It is standard catalog, so it means that if an item is there it is a coin.

Alexander from Cyprus
eucoins.byethost9.com
My suggestions https://t.me/enjoyyourcollection

cyprusalexander

Thank you for your opinions, all that is common for many commemorative coins. Though it seems, that these opinions are in obvious contradiction with the statement of Standard Catalog of World Coins: KM#1 (it is already written, just enough to read the first post twice). It is standard catalog, so it means that if an item is there it is a coin.

Not true, Krause is full of errors.

 

Like this Sahaara coin that is on Krause but Numista says is not official

N#4173

The year of issue is 2003.  The Standard Catalog of World Coins did not put this coin in catalog in 2004, and in 2005, and even in 2006. 

But then there is number ΚΜ#1. It means, that the decision was not made just in a moment. There should be documents used to recognize the coin.

Alexander from Cyprus
eucoins.byethost9.com
My suggestions https://t.me/enjoyyourcollection

Seems the old “IDAO - Bureau Africain d'Emission issues ” site is no longer online, there they used to sell all those fantasy coins with unrealistic minting numbers , the site was at the address www.africamint.com and is no longer available, everything looked like trying to be official, but was a private company.

 

I guess there is no doubt about the fantasy nature of those tokens.

Since Krause is now effectively  dead, Numista may well be the most reliable authority in the world in these matters.

Jamais l'or n'a perdu la plus petite occasion de se montrer stupide. -Balzac

6000 Francs / 4 Africa IDAO Coinage Numista (exonumia) page:

N#12820

We have source : 2008 Standard Catalog of World Coins by George S. Cuhaj (Krause Publications).
2012 Unusual World Coins by George S. Cuhaj (Krause Publications)

Here for example « Coin type Tokens (probes) » : https://en.m.ucoin.net/coin/burkina_faso-6000-francs-2003/?tid=50006

 

For us it is indeed an Exonumia ranking

X @NumisMedal

Mr. Midnight

Since Krause is now effectively  dead, Numista may well be the most reliable authority in the world in these matters.

yes

...you can run,  but you can't hide...

The site numismaster.com has taken over in the issuing of new KM numbers.

Referee of south atlantic islands

» Forum policy

使用されているタイムゾーンは UTC+2:00 です。
現在の時刻は {24時間表記の時間}:{分} です。