Antigua. Proposal to move gold and silver dollars’ be moved from Banknotes to Exonumia.

I propose that the following three non-circulating ‘commemorative gold and silver dollars’ produced by Antigua be moved from Banknotes to Exonumia.

What do people think?

Lets put it to a vote!

N#297453
N#326987
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/note259232.html
 

Isn't this the same as what's being discussed for the coin catalog.  https://en.numista.com/forum/topic125051.html  

IMO the type (NCLT, etc.) is not a parameter here; if they are legal tender, they are coins by definition and you can technically pay with them at face value. Then, coin catalogue.

My own personal view is that government backed legal tender currency is not exonumia.

In my opinion anything issued officially should stay where it is otherwise we open up a bottomless can of worms.

If they are legal tender then they are approved by the government and should not be part of Exonumia,

@rsirian1

Good points, well made. Please vote against the proposal accordingly!

Hibernia

@rsirian1

Good points, well made. Please vote against the proposal accordingly!

I'm not against it.  

Definitely NOT ‘Exonumia’!

The same goes for the ones from Belize.

Aidan.

Rejected ticket as to my understanding these are legal tender, then Banknote catalogue is correct.

These are just commemorative and made of an “uncommon” material.