First gold coin

52 posts

» Quick access to the last post

Hey guys, I'm a young collector and am thinking of getting my first gold coin soon, as my birthday is coming around and I've worked a little over the summer.

Does anyone have any advice on what I should get with a modest budget of around $300?

I would like it to be something old (pre 1950)

Thanks     
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
Sovereigns should be a must have.

Either that or Russian imperial coins, which have very nice engravings. If you want to get more than one gold coin, you should probably get 一分判金 (ichibu kin) which usually have a purity around 50%.

With that kind of money you should just buy a bunch of silver cheap.
Kenny

- Verifying your Asian and British-territorial coins everyday with the best quality photos and the best information.

Check out my Facebook, Kenneth Gucyski.
yeah so far i'm torn between a british sovereign or a US gold coin
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
Huh.

Sovereigns are pretty much the British and masculine counterpart of the St. Gauden's gold eagle. If I were you I'd choose the sovereign.
Kenny

- Verifying your Asian and British-territorial coins everyday with the best quality photos and the best information.

Check out my Facebook, Kenneth Gucyski.
With a budget of $300 you won't be able to buy a Sovereign however why not consider a half sovereign? I always thought they were better proportioned than their larger counterparts. The good news is that the increased price of gold means you can get a nice Victorian coin for pretty much the same price as a soulless modern issue.

Expect to pay around $260 for a nice circulated coin, slightly more for a slabbed and certified example. Unless you are VERY confident about the source and you ability to spot a fake I would recommend buying a coin certified by one of the top tier companies: NGC, PCGS, ANACS.
Non illegitimis carborundum est.  Excellent advice for all coins.
Make Numismatics Great Again!  
Hmm... I didn't even know about half sovereigns... Maybe I will go british although I do like this coin:https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces6158.html


But yeah I always buy graded for anything $100 or more. Here in Canada we have ICCS, but for a foreign coin it will probably be PGCS or NGC
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
half sovereign gets my vote!
Taking a break from swapping for a while, but still interested in pre 1799 Spanish coins, I will make time for that!

Looking for pre 1783 coins
What about a guinea ? I believe I have a spade guinea in my possession now ! Which was very dirty and it's nowhere near the thickness of the jetons !
I would buy a gold Helvetia.
引用する: dptashnyI would buy a gold Helvetia.
Hmm... I do like this one
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces3950.html
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
Who is a reliable dealer in the US for bullion coins? Anyone have experience?
引用する: @josephjkWho is a reliable dealer in the US for bullion coins? Anyone have experience?
Heritage is probably the best option but be aware that there is a buyer's premium to be paid on top of the bid price.

I'm guessing you are asking about items of numismatic interest rather than bullion? Anyone wanting to buy bullion purely for investment has a whole lot of PM dealers to choose from. I would certainly avoid eBay though, even certified coins are being faked now.
Non illegitimis carborundum est.  Excellent advice for all coins.
Make Numismatics Great Again!  
Thanks Phil..I was looking for investment bullion...like you said, I found a bunch of dealers when I googled it
引用する: @josephjkThanks Phil..I was looking for investment bullion...like you said, I found a bunch of dealers when I googled it
It's always a pleasure to help a Texan!
Non illegitimis carborundum est.  Excellent advice for all coins.
Make Numismatics Great Again!  
Their is also another option which you may wish to consider. When I start my coin collecting again I am going down the rout of Uncirculated date runs of lowish value coins. I am going to start off by collecting Elizabeth II Penny's all in Unc condition this will only cost (assuming the book is correct) about £12 which is nothing, Ok I will need to factor in postage as well and if I want the 1953 proof then budget another £7. Then I will move on to the George VI Penny's these are a lot more expensive book value of £201 all Unc not including proofs. My point is you could put together an impressive collection with the money you have and it will be good fun hunting down the coins you have decided to buy from various sources.

I think tho you should collect what pleases you artistically or historically rather than just buying gold for the sake of buying gold. Having said that gold is a truly stunning metal.
引用する: dptashnyI would buy a gold Helvetia.
I second that idea. Especially the 10 Francs!
Thanks guys for all the advice. Walder coins - I do something similar with canadian coins (collecting every year) but I don't care about the condition. And it would definitely help if I spent that money to get more of those silver victorian coins.

My current thinking is that I will go to a big coinshow in October and ask different dealers about what they suggest. If I am to get a gold coin, I want something old, whose numismatic value has just been surpassed by it's bullion value (or vice versa) so that if price of gold drops, I still have the value.

this is my list of possibilities so far:
British 1/2 sovereign or 1 sovereign
Australian 1/2 sovereign or 1 sovereign
Swiss gold coin (either 10 franken or 20 franken)
South Africa 1/2 pond
U.S. gold $1 or $2.5
Austrian Ducats

Again thanks for everyone's help
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
引用する: eminemThanks guys for all the advice. Walder coins - I do something similar with canadian coins (collecting every year) but I don't care about the condition. And it would definitely help if I spent that money to get more of those silver victorian coins.

My current thinking is that I will go to a big coinshow in October and ask different dealers about what they suggest. If I am to get a gold coin, I want something old, whose numismatic value has just been surpassed by it's bullion value (or vice versa) so that if price of gold drops, I still have the value.

this is my list of possibilities so far:
British 1/2 sovereign or 1 sovereign
Australian 1/2 sovereign or 1 sovereign
Swiss gold coin (either 10 franken or 20 franken)
South Africa 1/2 pond
U.S. gold $1 or $2.5

Again thanks for everyone's help
Look also for ducats.
引用する: dptashnyLook also for ducats.
my list has been revised  <:D
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
I'd go with the $2 1/2  Indian. It's cool because...
1. It's gold.
2. It's the only incuse US coin.
3. You can call it a quarter eagle and sound awesome.
It's a rather unique and interesting piece in my opinion. If you tried paying with that today, most people would probably refuse to accept it. Those coins are my favorite.
Free thinkers only thrive in history books.
~ Bayside - Howard
You could do the Sovereign for masculine  https://en.numista.com/forum/topic10219.html

  Or the 10 Franken for Beauty

  I am suprised that it was not on this forum, https://en.numista.com/forum/topic10186.html
Taking a break from swapping for a while, but still interested in pre 1799 Spanish coins, I will make time for that!

Looking for pre 1783 coins
If you want to get more coins for your money you could try getting a few of the smaller gold coins rather than 1 bigger one. Like the Mexican 2, 2.5 or 5 peso coins

http://www.lynncoins.com/MEXICO_Gold.htm
Not a bad idea but they are really small which makes it hard to see the design.
引用する: Walder CoinsNot a bad idea but they are really small which makes it hard to see the design.
Plus I like to feel coins, small coins and coins in capsules are like dead coins to me.
Yeah - personally I think that the bigger the coin, the better. That's why I love Canadian silver dollars
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
To each their own.  I don't like bigger coins, in fact I don't collect anything bigger than a half dollar.
引用する: neilithicTo each their own.  I don't like bigger coins, in fact I don't collect anything bigger than a half dollar.

I think the biggest collectable coins are 41mm in diameter.
my favourite size is the uk shilling, french franc, german mark, US quarter size, etc.  The perfect sized coin in my opinion.
引用する: dptashnyI think the biggest collectable coins are 41mm in diameter.
oh yeah?
http://www.mint.ca/store/coin/500-fine-silver-coin-the-spirit-of-haida-gwaii-mintage-100-2012-prod1340001

^look under specifications... (its 180mm)  :8D
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
引用する: eminem^look under specifications... (its 180mm)  :8D
Hmmmm, how is that going to fit in my 2x2 flips?
引用する: eminem
引用する: dptashnyI think the biggest collectable coins are 41mm in diameter.
oh yeah?
http://www.mint.ca/store/coin/500-fine-silver-coin-the-spirit-of-haida-gwaii-mintage-100-2012-prod1340001

^look under specifications... (its 180mm)  :8D
I mean in my opinion for me collection!  (8
no one likes belgian coins? 1877 20 francs is around 300$ for a nice vf-ef+
mexican gold is nice, im not sure bout price tho :D
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
引用する: 15turtlesno one likes belgian coins? 1877 20 francs is around 300$ for a nice vf-ef+
mexican gold is nice, im not sure bout price tho :D

Okay, maybe, well...
why not!
引用する: dptashny
引用する: 15turtlesno one likes belgian coins? 1877 20 francs is around 300$ for a nice vf-ef+
mexican gold is nice, im not sure bout price tho :D

Okay, maybe, well...
why not!
I take it you have a lot of Belgian coins?
引用する: Walder Coins
引用する: dptashny
引用する: 15turtlesno one likes belgian coins? 1877 20 francs is around 300$ for a nice vf-ef+
mexican gold is nice, im not sure bout price tho :D

Okay, maybe, well...
why not!
I take it you have a lot of Belgian coins?
Unless you count six as a lot, I don't! But, I have good ones and an amazing Belgian Congo coin.
I must admit I am no fan of Belgian coins but I did buy one which I quite like.
aha... i dont collect belgium coins, but i did buy a box recently... (2 mths ago) it was a shoebox of world coins, and in there it was a fraction of belgian coins (didnt count how much tho) in it. i found a gold coin in there..... fantasy find, but belgian gold and those 5 franc silvers are really nice... if you want sth relaxing to look at, just aesthetically pleasing, id say belgian gold or a helvetica. for sth that is just plain shining glory, i'd say the mexican ones (idk bout price) or as the other ppl said... american and british. they are all nice but it rlly depends on your taste. :P good luck in choosing one
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
Don't tell any one I said this but I don't actually like modern gold coins. If I was to buy a gold coin I would go ancient or Byzantine any day over anything made over the past 100 years or so.
I've got pleanty of belgian coins, but they're all silver.  I'd love to pick up some gold coins
No fans of the Krugerrand here?
引用する: KräftskivaNo fans of the Krugerrand here?
Not me.
OMG we forgot the krugerrand!

It's more for the aesthetically pleasing type of taste

They are pretty tho :D
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
My first gold coin was a 1967 Canada $20 gold coin. It was part of a set that my dad bought in 1967 and was issued to celebrate Canada's centennial (100th birthday). Dad paid $40 (issue price) for the entire set from the Royal Canadian Mint. Today, the gold content in this $20 gold coin is worth approximately $1000.00 CAD. I was 2 years old when Dad bought this coin for me. I may have to sell it soon to pay more medical bills. I once took it to a pawn shop but an hour later when back and bought it back. Currently, this is the only gold coin that I still have.
引用する: coinsoldierMy first gold coin was a 1967 Canada $20 gold coin. It was part of a set that my dad bought in 1967 and was issued to celebrate Canada's centennial (100th birthday). Dad paid $40 (issue price) for the entire set from the Royal Canadian Mint. Today, the gold content in this $20 gold coin is worth approximately $1000.00 CAD. I was 2 years old when Dad bought this coin for me. I may have to sell it soon to pay more medical bills. I once took it to a pawn shop but an hour later when back and bought it back. Currently, this is the only gold coin that I still have.
:(
that is very sad, and from what I understand (with you being in the Army), I believe it to be a great injustice that you would have to pay any medical bills at all. I hope you don't have to sell it

 :(
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
引用する: eminemthat is very sad, and from what I understand (with you being in the Army), I believe it to be a great injustice that you would have to pay any medical bills at all. I hope you don't have to sell it

 :(
perseverance is the key to everything. the world cannot be without logic. but to pay medical fees for serving your country is not logical. best of luck  <:D  (again)
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
For $300 there are several Canadian coins that you may want to consider.
canadian coins? I thought the canadian sovereigns and 5 + 10 dollar coins were all worth over $300 just for gold value
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
What about a British India mohur or 1/2 mohur ?
there is a 5 dollar gold (canada) listed in the charlston standard as 280$  (forgot which year and grade... oops)
i will check later
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
Hey, we are all still wondering what you're getting? Go ahead and get one, the suspense is killing me ;)
Taking a break from swapping for a while, but still interested in pre 1799 Spanish coins, I will make time for that!

Looking for pre 1783 coins
I will... there is a large coin show in October (the day before my birthday) called Torex, and that is where I will make up my mind. Don't worry, I will tell you guys what I chose to do.
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.

» Forum policy

使用されているタイムゾーンは UTC+2:00 です。
現在の時刻は {24時間表記の時間}:{分} です。